When did we lose sight of the game?

Now that I’ve got more of my old gaming things out on display, I’ve been spending some time flicking through the various rule books and looking at the miniatures and it strikes me that something has changed. The game has gone. The fun has gone.

I’ve got the new Warhammer 40k 6th edition rulebook and I’ve got the 3rd edition Warhammer Fantasy Battle rulebook. At some point in the last 20 odd years something has changed.

Now, I’m not stupid. I know this change has happened. I’ve picked up enough from various podcasts and blogs and I can see with my own eyes how much Games Workshop has changed. But it really makes me sad that money has taken over what should be an enjoyable hobby. The old books included cardboard representations of units and special weapons for you to cut out, copy and use in battle. The Blood Bowl Companion book includes various templates and even includes a +2 bonus if y0ur cheerleader models are painted. This to me says that the important thing was to play the game, not buy the models. The best 40k or Fantasy Battle player shouldn’t be the one that can afford to buy and paint the best models or afford the most Codex supplements. In part that’s why I love Blood Bowl and why I think it is perfect. I need a minimum of 11 miniatures up to a maximum of 16. The rules are simple, I don’t need special terrain or carry cases to carry flyers. This isn’t about Blood Bowl though it’s the principle of gaming. Right back to D&D where you didn’t even need minis – the rules, a few dice, paper, pencil and you were away. I’m starting to explore the brave new world of tabletop, card and roleplaying games in the hope of finding some new loves. I know they are out there.

I don’t know when this change happened, but I know it’s not one that has made this a better world. I wonder how the original designers of these games must really feel now…deep down. Not in the glossy brochure that is White Dwarf. Looking at the pictures of them in the old rule books these are not people that needed miniatures to have a good time with tabletop games. The game is in the skill and imagination of the players.

Warhammer Fantasy Battle rule book

Warhammer Fantasy Battle rule book

Warhammer Fantasy Battle cut outs

Warhammer Fantasy Battle cut outs

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “When did we lose sight of the game?

  1. I don’t think I can agree that ‘we’ have lost sight of the hobby. Sure, GW (and other mini companies) have changed their product to make money in a different way; they are supposed to try and make a profit after all. But that doesn’t change what gamers can do, except in terms of playing in official tournaments. If you still want to use printouts to represent your army on the tabletop, no-one will stop you. One of my friends does exactly that for WFB.

    I think that part of the change to remove templates in the book (as per your pictures) has resulted in boxed ‘starter’ sets which include sme miniatures anyway, so I don’t really regard that as a problem. Luckily for me I play in a group where proxying is the norm so I can pick and choose whether to buy any specific mini anyway.

    • I agree with the ‘we’ part, but I do think that the manner in which games and rules have become monetized through starter sets, boxed units and expensive and expansive rules means that we, the gamers, are restricted by how we can play even at home.

      I’m pleased that you have a group of sensible mates to play games with, it’s something I hope to build up over time. Stick it to ‘the man’ 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s